Crime is falling in North Carolina, but more jails across the state are over capacity as local governments house more suspects — the result of a state law enacted last year after the stabbing death of a woman on a Charlotte commuter train, according to a new analysis of public data.
Jails across North Carolina held an average of 22,956 people in July 2026, up 17.5% from a year earlier according to the Southern Coalition for Social Justice, a Durham-based civil rights group that analyzed data from the state Department of Health and Human Services.
That 17.5% increase in jail inmates comes despite crime falling across the board in North Carolina: In the first half of this year, WRAL previously reported, violent crimes dropped by 5.8%, drug crimes dropped by 3.2%, financial crimes dropped 2.1% and property crimes dropped by 11.8% compared to 2025.
Nevertheless, the state’s growing jail population broke two records this year, according to the report: It’s the biggest single-year jump since the state began collecting jail data in 1986, as well as the most people who have ever been jailed.
The 2026 jail population of 22,956 people has surpassed the previous peak of 20,726 in 2019, the group reported. Accordingly, almost 40% of the jails that reported population data to DHHS are over capacity, the group said in its analysis, which was released this week.
“Overcrowded jails are dangerous places for the people locked inside and for the people who work there,” Jake Sussman, chief counsel for justice system reform at the Southern Coalition for Social Justice, said in a statement.
Each jail in the state is run separately, by the local county sheriff. Thirty-eight of the 98 jails reporting data to the state DHHS were operating above capacity in the first half of 2026, up from 31 a year earlier, and another 15 are approaching capacity, the coalition said in its report. Jails in Scotland, Warren, Chowan, Greene and Halifax counties are running at more than 150% capacity, the group reported.
The declining crime rate isn’t only a recent phenomenon, either. The crime rate in North Carolina has fallen every year since at least 2020according to state data from that time frame.
‘Iryna’s law’ impact
The reason more people are in jail, even though fewer crimes and arrests are occurring, is a new state law passed by the Republican-led legislature and signed into law by Democratic Gov. Josh Stein last year.
Starting in December 2025, Iryna’s Law now requires stricter scrutiny on judges and magistrates when considering pre-trial release. It also bans one type of cashless bail in North Carolina. The effect has been a growing jail population, in counties urban and rural.
When Republican state lawmakers first introduced the bill, state Senate leader Phil Berger said the goal of keeping more accused criminals behind bars, before trial, was to end “atrocious policies pushed by out-of-touch politicians and court officials that prioritize a perverted vision or version of equity and politicized social justice over real and tangible justice.”
But some critics have said the bail policies have backfired, causing public safety risks.
Earlier this year Wake County Sheriff Willie Rowe said he has been urging local police chiefs to tell their officers to stop arresting people for minor crimessince the jail Rowe runs can’t hold any more inmates. The Wake County jail is built to hold 1,574 inmates but in recent months has sometimes had close to 2,000 inmates packed into overcrowded cells, Rowe told WRAL in August.
The new law was created in response to the killing of Iryna Zarutska, a 23-year-old woman who was stabbed to death in a seemingly random attack on a commuter train in Charlotte. Decarlos Brown, who is charged with murder in the case, had been released from jail as he awaited trial on misdemeanor charges in a separate case at the time of Zarutska’s death.
Republican sponsors of the bill said it was needed to prevent more deaths like Zarutska’s. Democrats said it should have included more provisions focused on preventing violent crime, arguing that it focused too much on punishments doled out after a crime has already been committed. Stein signed the bill into law, echoing many of those concerns.
One of the bill’s main Republican authors, state Sen. Danny Britt, told WRAL earlier this year for the “Decades of Warning” documentary that he tried to get more funding for mental health as part of the law but was denied by fellow Republicans.
“I expressed that without adequate funding for mental health and those that are justice-involved mental health individuals, we’re not going to be able to accomplish anything that we want to accomplish,” Britt said at the time.
The Southern Coalition for Social Justice said the law’s effect on growing jail populations is unfair to those accused of a crime, who are still innocent until proven guilty yet often given no opportunity to go free while they await trial.
“In less than a year, Iryna’s Law has put thousands more people behind bars who have not been convicted of anything,” Sussman said. “Many of them are caged right now simply because they can’t afford to pay for their freedom. Others are held under a blanket presumption of detention that ignores who they are or how strong the evidence is. The law is creating outcomes that undermine, rather than improve, public safety.”
In Wake County over the past year, the number of people arrested has fallen nearly 15% — despite the county’s population growth, according to the report. Nevertheless the county’s jail exceeds capacity, driven by a 114% surge in the number of people held pretrial without bond.
“This law has created a crisis that now needs intervention,” Sussman said.
Source: www.wral.com



