• Home  
  • Lula’s Judicial Reform Plan Could Reshape Brazil’s Supreme Court
Lula's Judicial Reform Plan Could Reshape Brazil's Supreme Court
- Crime & Justice

Lula’s Judicial Reform Plan Could Reshape Brazil’s Supreme Court

Brazil’s President and reelection candidate Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva attends a ceremony to announce investments in security at the headquarters of Highway Federal Police in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, on September 18, 2026. Photo by MAURO PIMENTEL / AFP via Getty Images The Briefing: Lula’s government plans to task a revamped Ministry of Justice

Brazil’s President and reelection candidate Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva attends a ceremony to announce investments in security at the headquarters of Highway Federal Police in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, on September 18, 2026.
Photo by MAURO PIMENTEL / AFP via Getty Images

The Briefing:

  • Lula’s government plans to task a revamped Ministry of Justice with leading judicial reform negotiations beginning in early 2027.
  • The pro-government Grupo Prerrogativas proposed single 12-year terms for STF and STJ justices alongside age and diversity rules, opening a public platform that drew dozens of submissions in its first week.
  • Lula could appoint up to 4 Supreme Court justices and at least 6 Superior Court of Justice members between 2027 and 2030.
  • STF President Edson Fachin set a December 19 deadline for his working group’s final report — but members are now pushing to delay the conclusion to mid-2027.
  • At least 74 constitutional amendment proposals on STF restructuring are currently stalled in Congress.

Brazil’s President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva is positioning a sweeping judicial overhaul as the defining institutional agenda of his fourth term — with a restructured Ministry of Justice at the helm and fixed 12-year mandates for Supreme Court justices now firmly on the table.

This is no longer a vague campaign promise. Lula’s inner circle is actively drafting the architecture; the reform has a 48-page blueprint from allied lawyers, and the Supreme Court itself is now navigating internal disagreements over how fast — and how far — its own counterproposal should go.

A New Ministry Architecture — and a Power Center for Reform

The Planalto’s plan calls for splitting the current Ministry of Justice and Public Security into two distinct offices. A new, standalone Ministry of Public Security would absorb a portion of the current structure’s secretariats. The resulting Ministry of Justice would retain the national secretariats for Justice, Access to Justice, and Legislative Affairs — preserving its institutional weight — with the government also evaluating the absorption of additional portfolio areas.

Critically, the restructured ministry would take ownership of all institutional negotiations with the Brazilian National Congress and the STF over judicial changes — a role Lula’s team is treating as strategically central. Sources cited by O Globo and CNN Brasil indicate the government is also evaluating the revival of a dedicated judicial reform secretariat, mirroring a structure used during Lula’s first term in 2003.

Marco Aurélio de Carvalho, coordinator of the Grupo Prerrogativas — the collective of pro-government lawyers and jurists that drafted the reform blueprint — is among the names being considered to lead the new ministry. The choice would signal an unusually direct pipeline between civil society advocacy and institutional policymaking.

Three Pillars, One Constitutional Amendment

In a November 8 address to the nation, Lula framed the reform around three non-negotiable axes: ending de facto lifetime tenure on the courts, creating a consultative council for appointment criteria, and imposing stricter ethics rules on magistrates.

The Grupo Prerrogativas document — released November 10 and opened for public consultation — provides the most detailed roadmap yet. Its nine thematic axes have already drawn 86 proposals from 33 people and organizations in just its first week online.

Fixed mandates: A single, non-renewable 12-year term for STF and STJ justices, with the minimum appointment age raised from 35 to 45 and a maximum entry age of 63 — effectively barring the decades-long stays on the bench that currently define the court’s composition.

Diversity Mandates and an Ethics Overhaul

Diversity quotas: The 11-seat STF would be required to include at least five women and three Black justices — a structural demographic shift from the court’s current composition.

The proposed Code of Ethics would expressly prohibit justices from receiving gifts, accepting sponsored travel or lodging, participating in private events, or earning outside compensation.

Jurisdiction and Procedural Reform

Unified rulings and jurisdiction reform: The proposal would replace the practice of publishing lengthy individual votes with a single collegiate pronouncement, and would restrict privileged forum — the special jurisdictional privilege routing cases involving senior officials to the STF — pushing them instead to first-instance courts.

BRAZIL-ELECTION-RUNOFF-VOTE
A view of Brazil’s Justice Palace building in Brasilia, on October 25, 2026, during the presidential runoff election. Brazilians head to the polls for a runoff between President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and right-wing senator Flavio Bolsonaro that will determine whether Brazil remains one of the few leftist nations in the region or joins a regional swing to the right championed by US President Donald Trump, a Bolsonaro ally.
Photo by Igo ESTRELA / AFP via Getty Images

The Stakes: Lula’s Appointment Window

Over the 2027–2030 term, he could appoint up to four STF justices — roughly a third of the 11-member court — and at least six members of the STJ, Brazil’s top court for non-constitutional matters. That appointment power, combined with a structural reform agenda, would give the government substantial leverage over the composition and operating rules of Brazil’s highest courts simultaneously.

Fachin, Gilmar, and a Court Divided

Inside the STF, the Executive’s maneuver is being watched with considerable wariness — and the court is far from speaking with one voice. Speaking at a public event on November 16, Chief Justice Edson Fachin drew a clear line: any structural reform must respect judicial independence and constitutional guarantees, and must not convert itself into a tool for weakening the courts.

Three days earlier, on November 13, Justice Gilmar Mendes — the court’s longest-serving member — added his own note of caution. Mendes warned specifically against stripping the STF of its criminal jurisdictionpointing to Operation Car Wash as evidence that first-instance courts are not immune to institutional failures either. His remarks signal that any reform proposal threatening the court’s prosecutorial reach will face resistance from within the bench itself.

The STF’s Own Proposal: Behind Schedule and Under Pressure

Since June 2026, Fachin has led a 19-member working group of jurists — comprising ministers, magistrates, lawyers and professors — tasked with producing a court-originated reform proposal. The group has drawn contributions from 87 institutions. Fachin initially set December 19, the last day of Brazil’s 2026 judicial calendar, as the final delivery deadline. But members of the group are now pushing to extend the timeline into the first half of 2027arguing the discussions need more time to mature and that the Executive and Legislative branches must be brought into a broader republican consensus before any proposal is finalized. Internal deadlines have already been repeatedly pushed back.

Fachin has also urged dialogue across branches and institutions so any judiciary reform preserves judicial independence while building broader consensus.

The parallel tracks — Lula’s allies pushing for a 2027 constitutional amendment, and an STF working group behind schedule and internally divided — set up a defining confrontation when Congress reconvenes in January. With at least 74 constitutional amendment proposals on the subject already sitting dormant in Congress, the question is no longer whether Brazil’s judiciary will be reformed — but which version of reform survives, and on whose timetable.

© {{Year}} Latin Times. All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Source: www.latintimes.com

About Us

Toolq Media Is a Global News Platform Covering the Latest Developments and Breaking Stories from Around The World, Including World News, Business, Finance, Technology, Health, Politics, Science, Entertainment, Sports, and More.

Toolq

Toolq @2026. All Rights Reserved.