There were no royal walkabouts with screaming crowds behind barricades. In fact, there were no crowds at all to greet the Prince and Princess of Wales.
In the sweltering streets of Mumbai, home to 22 million people in India’s financial and entertainment capital, most inhabitants in the busy neighbourhoods, where cars honk incessantly and pedestrians edge past entire families sleeping on the pavements, have more immediate concerns.
Over three days last week on their first major joint overseas visit since 2022, William and Kate trialled a new approach as they set out to celebrate the city hosting the heir to the throne’s £50m Earthshot Prize, and support UK-India relations on behalf of the Foreign Office.
Initially there had been discussions about making this at least a five-day visit to Mumbai and Delhi. Some Foreign Office officials were said to have wanted to make it a more traditional eight-day tour to various locations. But William, 44, who does a fraction of the trips on behalf of the taxpayer that his father undertook at the same age, now thinks that a couple of three-day visits each year are all that is needed in a world connected by social media. A consideration might be that the couple are pacing the return to duties of the Princess of Wales, who has announced she is to appear in a new television documentary charting her journey through her cancer diagnosis and recovery, or because they have a young family at home – but that is not the line being pushed.
The boiled-down result was a sterile, stage-managed visit lacking authenticity, despite attempts by some in the media bubble to present it as a diplomatic tour de force. It was sanitised, unlike the air above Mumbai, where pollution kills more than 5,000 people a year. A pall of smog made visibility poor, despite William’s praise for India’s rapid development of green technology at the environmental awards ceremony.
“This is not the real India,” said one Delhi-based journalist, outside a gleaming high-rise building housing a school teaching women traditional crafts. “We’ve gone from one shiny new building to another, but it’s all a facade.”
The royal couple, who stayed in the Oberoi Hotel – where the most expensive suites cost £6,150 a night – took a ride on the gleaming new metro line between two cordoned-off stations with no other passengers in sight. Earlier they had played street cricket with India’s sporting superstar Sachin Tendulkar and some children in an area cleared of rubbish next to roads newly repaved for their visit.
At Bombay high court last Wednesday, two judges criticised state and city authorities for putting on a “temporary show” to spruce up the area for the royal visit, while doing nothing to tackle the mountains of plastic and other rubbish that litter the streets and beaches every other day.
Bollywood stars on the green carpet at the glittering Earthshot Prize Awards gushed about how much India loved the royals. But journalists based in Delhi and Mumbai said that only the foreign-educated elite really knew about them, while the rest of the nation of 1.48 billion were unaware or indifferent. By some estimates, up to 430 million people belong to the Indian middle class.
“Even most people in the middle class are just trying to make ends meet,” said one reporter. “They don’t really think about the royals and they don’t think about environmental issues until something affects them like a flood.”
Some talked about how Britain’s clampdown on student visas had damaged sentiment towards the UK and led young people to go to university in Australia or Canada instead. There was more evidence of hostility in the Times of Indiawhere novelist Siddharth Dhanvant Shanghvi detailed complaints dating back to the colonial era and criticised the couple for not sampling real Mumbai life, under a headline reading: Why do we still fawn over British royalty?
As a veteran of perhaps 100 royal overseas visits over almost 23 years as a royal reporter, I spent more time than usual speaking to local journalists on this trip. It was an unexpected bonus after the cosy cartel of British newspaper reporters refused to allow me to join the UK media pool on the grounds that, although I have written about the royals for The Observer for two and a half years, I am freelance.
In royal reporting, the journalistic equivalent of isolation on a foreign tour is to be relegated to what is known as the fixed point and excluded from the UK media pools that share words, photos and video. If you are not in the pool, you don’t see what the royal couple do at close range, you can’t hear what they say and nobody is going to tell you until you read it in their publications later.
If you are not in the media pool, you don’t see what they royal couple do at close range, you can’t hear what they say and nobody is going to tell you
If you are not in the media pool, you don’t see what they royal couple do at close range, you can’t hear what they say and nobody is going to tell you
In years gone by, when the reporters were mainly men, there would be regular punch-ups after one journalist double-crossed another or ripped out a payphone to stop rivals filing stories. These days the coup de grâce is delivered by getting a rival thrown out of a WhatsApp group, removed from a briefing, or excluded from a pool.
But under a monarch who wants to increase diversity and inclusion in all aspects of the workings of the institution, it may have to intervene in a dispute which, for complicated reasons, has left Victoria Jones of the Shutterstock agency as the only female photographer regularly on these foreign trips, yet one who is banned from both picture pools, leading to accusations of a boys’ club.
William and Kate’s office is happy to intervene if the bosses are offended. Kensington Palace, according to multiple sources, refused to allow the international news agency Agence France-Presse to send photographers from London with the UK media pool on this and other foreign trips. Neither side would discuss the matter but it follows a row two years ago after AFP’s global news director, Phil Chetwynd, said Kensington Palace was no longer a “trusted source” and indirectly compared it to North Korea after Kate admitted doctoring a family photo later withdrawn from circulation by major news agencies.
The ban has sent a chill through others. “It does make you think and be wary of doing anything that will upset them. Psychologically, it’s something that’s there. You don’t want to put out a picture that makes them look bad,” one photographer said.
Some of the reporters, too, joke about feeling the need to describe just about every tour as a triumph while privately taking a different view and questioning William and Kate’s work ethic.
Some think it would be healthier if there was a bit less cheerleading and more scrutiny from newspapers, with more intermittent interest in the royal story.
On their last evening, William and Kate flew to Delhi to meet the Indian prime minister, Narendra Modi, who in 12 years in power has never held a press conference or answered a barrage of challenging questions from journalists. They got on well, apparently.
Photograph Ian Vogler via Getty Images
Source: observer.co.uk



