• Home  
  • What the Death Penalty Says About Us
What the Death Penalty Says About Us
- Crime & Justice

What the Death Penalty Says About Us

BYLINE: Taylor McNeil, Tufts Now Newswise — This month, the governor of California commuted the death sentences of 548 people on death row in that state to life in prison without the option of parole. “I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them,” he wrote. Earlier in the fall, state authorities in Tennessee attempted

BYLINE: Taylor McNeil, Tufts Now

Newswise — This month, the governor of California commuted the death sentences of 548 people on death row in that state to life in prison without the option of parole. “I have concluded the state cannot morally kill them,” he wrote.

Earlier in the fall, state authorities in Tennessee attempted to execute a death row inmate, Christa Gail Pike, but failed.

Both cases brought renewed attention to the death penalty in the United States, one of 53 countries that still have it on their law books. In the U.S., 23 states have banned capital punishment, but the others still allow it, as does the federal government.

The death penalty is considered to be the ultimate form of retributive justice—a punishment given in response to a crime, proportional to the severity of the offense. But is retributive justice itself moral? Professor of philosophy Erin Kelly addressed that issue in her book The Limits of Blame: Rethinking Punishment and Responsibility.

“The death penalty points toward a retributive philosophy of criminal punishment, which is the view that the state ought to punish criminal actors because that’s what they deserve,” she says. Kelly is skeptical of a “just deserts” approach to justice. Her book considers the “psychological and situational vulnerabilities of justice-involved people to challenge common assumptions about crime and punishment, especially the view that retributive punishment is a requirement of justice,” she says.

Currently she is researching the philosophy of restorative justice. “I’m interested in alternatives to retributive thinking, because I don’t think that the retributive paradigm is helping us to be a morally healthy society,” she says. Instead, “I’m interested in restorative justice as an approach to the harm that crime does that attempts to think through how we might work together to heal the injuries that have been caused to the victims of crime and in the lives of people who commit crimes, and to understand why these things are happening.”

Tufts Now spoke to her recently about the death penalty and its implications.

How does the death penalty fit into a philosophy of justice?

It seems clear that the idea of retribution or deserved punishment is driving the death penalty, because the other purposes of punishment that philosophers of punishment might cite to justify the practice don’t get you all the way to the death penalty.

The death penalty doesn’t seem necessary to protect society from dangerous criminal actors, because incarceration is an alternative form of incapacitation.

So it looks like the death penalty stands on retribution as the basis of its justification. It’s an extreme punishment, because it’s irreversible and it’s more intense than anything else we could do to a person legally, since we’ve outlawed torture.

Ultimately, I think it symbolizes the judgment that this person’s life has no value. It’s dehumanizing, and some would say it dehumanizes the society that’s willing to impose it.

Are there other consequences of the death penalty?

I think it also has the effect of making other punishments seem less severe than they are, simply because they fall short of death. One unintended consequence of the death penalty abolition movement was that life in prison without parole seems more acceptable when compared to the death penalty, so some states looking for alternatives might view it as a good alternative policy.

And in fact, life in prison without parole has been increasingly used over the years. In fact, according to The Sentencing Projectmore people now are serving life without parole than ever before—68% more than in 2003. A life without parole sentence is a very intense and heavily punitive sentence. Some people refer to it as “the other death penalty.”

It deprives people of hope, and that to me is dehumanizing. To treat another person as a person means looking at them as capable of reflection and change, and to deprive them of all hope of being able to change and lead a different kind of life in society seems cruel.

Even if the number of people who are executed each year in the United States is relatively small—37 people so far this year—compared to, say, the 200,000 people serving life sentences (and the 56,000 serving life without parole), the fact that the death penalty is a possibility seems to signal something really unhealthy about how we think about other people and what we owe one another as members of a democratic society.

How should a society deal with someone who is a grave danger to others?

I think that incarceration is sometimes the only reasonable option if a person has caused serious harm and poses a serious threat in the near future.

But a sentence that doesn’t permit the possibility of revisiting the person’s options to be released back into society with the support that they need to be successful seems shortsighted and unduly pessimistic about a person’s capacity to think and change.

Many people with mental health problems have problems that are treatable, which could render them suitable for release in society. Other people grow and mature and change their thinking.

Who is most affected by the death penalty?

Disproportionately, you have people facing the harshest penalty who come from the most disadvantaged backgrounds, and in many cases, suffer from intellectual disabilities or some form of mental illness.

Even somebody who believes in moral desert—the intuitive basis of retribution—should be concerned about the mitigation of responsibility that comes from the recognition of mental illness, intellectual disability, and severely disadvantaged backgrounds, including the deprivation of basic opportunities to meet one’s needs and the exposure to violence and trauma.

Do you think views will shift in this country about the death penalty and retributive justice?

I haven’t seen a lot of change. I think there’s an increased skepticism about the death penalty because of the exoneration of some people on death row based on DNA evidence that indicates that they were not guilty of the crimes they were convicted of. That these individuals were convicted shakes people’s confidence in the criminal justice system, but not because they don’t believe in retribution and moral desert, but because they think that justice is not being done.

I think that retribution as a philosophy of criminal punishment is still very popular, and it’s hard to unsettle people’s adherence to that philosophy if they find it intuitive.

From about 1900 to the 1970s, the U.S. criminal justice system often stressed rehabilitation vs. retribution. Do you see that ever going back to focus more on rehabilitation?

I don’t know the answer to that, but there has been a growing movement in the direction of restorative justice as a paradigm for thinking about possible responses to crimes, a kind of community-based justice that would seek to resolve the harm that a crime has caused to an individual or community without formal punishment. Restorative justice focuses on what the responsible person can do to remediate harm that they have caused.

Although it’s a small movement in comparison to the massive carceral state that we are faced with, there are people working on these practices and the philosophies surrounding them in ways that are potentially transformative at the local community level. Their efforts provide some scaffolding for broader change in thinking about criminal justice. That is a hopeful direction in the midst of an intensely punitive approach in this country to crime and justice.

https://now.tufts.edu/2026/11/16/what-death-penalty-says-about-us

Source: www.newswise.com

About Us

Toolq Media Is a Global News Platform Covering the Latest Developments and Breaking Stories from Around The World, Including World News, Business, Finance, Technology, Health, Politics, Science, Entertainment, Sports, and More.

Toolq

Toolq @2026. All Rights Reserved.