New analysis of WEX customer transaction data highlights rising fuel expenses, differences in purchasing behavior, and opportunities for fleet managers to evaluate operating costs.
Commercial fleets continued purchasing roughly the same amount of fuel despite rising prices in 2026, according to a new report from WEX examining fuel spending and purchasing patterns.
The company released its WEX Index: The Fleet and Mobility Spend Report, which analyzes proprietary transaction data from January through September 2026 to examine how commercial fleets responded to higher fuel prices, where drivers purchased fuel, and opportunities to manage operating expenses.
The findings are based on WEX’s customer transaction data, drawn from a business serving more than 600,000 mobility customers. Although the dataset provides insight into fleet purchasing behavior, it does not necessarily represent the broader commercial fleet industry.
Fuel Prices Increase While Consumption Remains Steady
According to WEX, the average U.S. fuel price reflected in its data increased approximately 43% in the third quarter of 2026 compared with the same period in 2025, rising from $3.38 to $4.85 per gallon.
Despite the increase, gallons purchased remained essentially unchanged across WEX’s Mobility segment.
The report identified several areas where fleet purchasing decisions could influence operating costs.
Key findings include:
- Fuel purchasing costs: WEX found that 38.1% of North American local fleets analyzed paid more than the local WEX Fuel Price Index benchmark, while 36.1% paid approximately the benchmark price and 25.8% paid below it.
- Premium gasoline purchases: Premium fuel accounted for 7.6% of gasoline transactions across the five industries examined, with an average price difference of 78 cents per gallon compared with regular gasoline.
- Potential fuel savings: WEX estimated up to $86.9 million in potential savings through the third quarter of 2026 if vehicles that did not require premium gasoline used regular fuel instead.
- Driver spending differences: Among fleets with five or more drivers, 81.4% had at least one driver whose fuel spending exceeded the fleet average.
Higher driver spending does not necessarily indicate misuse or inefficient purchasing. Differences in routes, vehicle types, mileage, and operating requirements can influence fuel expenses.
Which Fleet Industries Paid More for Fuel?
WEX also examined differences in fuel purchasing costs across several commercial fleet industries.
Manufacturing fleets had the highest percentage of fleets paying above the local fuel price benchmark among the industries highlighted, followed by retail trade.
The findings reflect transactions within WEX’s customer base and may not represent fuel purchasing patterns across each industry as a whole.
The report notes that purchasing fuel above the local benchmark is not always avoidable. Driver schedules, route requirements, and station availability can influence where vehicles refuel.
For fleet managers, the findings point to the importance of evaluating fuel prices alongside operational factors, including the time and mileage required to reach lower-cost stations.
Using Fleet Data to Identify Spending and Operational Risks
Beyond fuel prices, the WEX Index examines how transaction data can help fleet managers identify spending variations and potential operational risks.
The report found that 81.4% of fleets with at least five drivers had one or more drivers spending above their fleet’s average.
WEX suggests that fleet managers review unusual transactions alongside driver assignments, routes, and vehicle requirements before determining whether additional action is necessary.
The report also examines fuel purchasing activity outside typical business hours. Weekday overnight transactions, between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m., accounted for approximately 6.7% of transactions across industries.
For fleets operating overnight routes or around-the-clock services, those transactions may reflect normal business activity rather than suspicious behavior.
WEX recommends establishing spending baselines, comparing purchases with local fuel price benchmarks, and using transaction monitoring tools to identify unusual patterns.
Vehicle Replacement Decisions and Total Cost of Ownership
The report also considers how vehicle replacement decisions could influence long-term fleet operating expenses.
Sawatch Labs, a WEX company, analyzed telematics data from 8,798 vehicles in U.S. and European fleets to evaluate potential electric vehicle replacements.
The analysis identified 27% of the vehicles as candidates for EV replacement. According to the company’s modeling, recommended replacements could generate average savings of $16,595 per vehicle, representing a 15% reduction in total cost of ownership over the vehicle’s service life.
These figures represent modeled estimates rather than verified savings from completed replacements.
Actual costs depend on vehicle application, mileage, energy prices, charging access, and other operating requirements.
The findings emphasize the importance of evaluating individual vehicle use cases and total cost of ownership when making replacement decisions, rather than applying the same strategy across an entire fleet.
What Fleet Managers Can Take From the Findings
WEX recommends several practices for evaluating fleet operating costs, including establishing a fuel spending baseline, comparing transactions against local market prices, monitoring purchasing patterns, and reassessing vehicle replacement options.
“Fleets can’t control the price of fuel, but they can control how they respond to it,” said Melissa Smith, CEO and president of WEX. “The WEX Index gives the mobility sector a fixed point of reference built from real transactions by real fleets.”
WEX said the inaugural report will serve as a baseline for future editions, allowing comparisons of fleet purchasing and spending trends over time.
The full report is available through the WEX Index resource page.
Source: www.automotive-fleet.com



