A study published in the journal Health & Justice reveals distinct gender-specific patterns in criminal justice involvement among Post-9/11 veterans, highlighting that while younger age and alcohol use disorder are shared risk factors, problematic anger is uniquely associated with justice system contact for women, whereas history of suicide attempts and homelessness are significant for men. The research, which analyzed data from 1,360 combat-deployed veterans, provides a nuanced understanding of how mental health, substance use, and psychosocial factors intersect to shape legal system involvement after military service. By examining a gender-balanced sample, the authors aim to address the growing population of women veterans and the need for targeted, patient-centered interventions that account for these divergent risk profiles.
The study utilized a nationally representative, gender-balanced sample of 1,360 Post-9/11 veterans, with a mean age of 37.49 years and 51.3% of the participants identifying as women. This demographic composition is significant because, although men remain the overwhelming majority of the veteran population, women represent a rapidly growing demographic group served in the Veterans Health Administration.
Criminal justice involvement was defined in the study as being arrested and charged with a crime after deployment, a metric measured through self-report. The researchers acknowledged that this method may not capture the full spectrum of justice involvement, such as the frequency, type, or severity of legal contact.
Overall, 15.0% of the veterans in the study reported post-deployment justice involvement. This prevalence rate breaks down to 11.3% of veteran women and 18.9% of veteran men, a difference that was statistically significant.
The study identified several factors associated with a higher likelihood of post-deployment justice involvement in both veteran women and men. Younger age was a significant predictor, with each one-year increase in age associated with lower odds of criminal justice system involvement for both genders. Specifically, for women, the odds ratio was 0.951, and for men, it was 0.957. Additionally, a provisional diagnosis of alcohol use disorder was linked to significantly higher odds of justice involvement across both groups. Women who screened positive for alcohol use disorder had 3.49 times higher odds of involvement, while men had 2.85 times higher odds. These shared correlates highlight the importance of addressing substance use and age-related vulnerabilities in prevention efforts.
In contrast, the study uncovered distinct gender-specific correlates that were not shared between men and women. Among veteran women only, higher levels of problematic anger were significantly associated with criminal justice system involvement. Each one-point increase in the severity of problematic anger was associated with a 9% greater odds of justice involvement among women. This finding suggests that anger management and emotional regulation may be critical areas for intervention for women veterans. The association between anger and legal contact may be influenced by social and institutional sanctions that women face when expressing anger, a dynamic that warrants further investigation in the context of post-deployment reintegration.
Among veteran men only, several other factors were significantly associated with criminal justice involvement. A lifetime history of suicide attempt was linked to 2.76 times higher odds of justice involvement, while a history of post-deployment homelessness was associated with 3.67 times higher odds. These findings underscore the importance of assessing for and addressing suicide risk and housing instability among male veterans. In a unique finding, a provisional diagnosis of somatoform disorder was associated with lower odds of criminal justice involvement among men, with an odds ratio of 0.400. The authors suggest that individuals with somatoform disorders may be more likely to utilize healthcare services, potentially connecting them to supportive services earlier and discouraging behaviors that lead to legal contact.
The study also noted that involvement in the justice system did not significantly differ on the basis of race or ethnicity for either gender in this sample. However, the authors caution that small sample sizes among minoritized racial/ethnic groups limited the statistical power to detect such associations. This contrasts with prior research that has documented elevated rates of justice involvement among minoritized groups, particularly Black veterans. The cross-sectional design of the study precludes conclusions about the directionality or causal nature of the observed associations, meaning that while these factors are linked to justice involvement, it is not possible to determine whether they cause it or are consequences of it.
The findings have several important clinical, social, and policy implications for supporting veterans during the transition from military to civilian life. The study supports the connection between alcohol use, history of suicide attempts, and history of homelessness among justice-involved veterans, highlighting the need for continued universal screening for these risks within the Veterans Health Administration. For women veterans, the unique association between problematic anger and justice involvement suggests that screening for anger and providing targeted interventions focused on emotion regulation may be particularly valuable. These interventions could help mitigate the risk of legal contact and support successful reintegration into civilian life.
Additionally, the results underscore the need for increased attention to the experiences of younger veterans, who may be particularly vulnerable to criminal justice involvement following deployment. Younger service members often face challenges securing stable employment upon returning to civilian life, which can contribute to instability and increased risk of legal issues. Facilitating connections to educational and vocational resources through the Department of Veterans Affairs may be an important strategy for supporting successful transition and reducing the risk of justice involvement. Clinicians and other providers can play a crucial role in helping veterans navigate these systems by discussing available resources and facilitating connections to services, including mental health and substance use treatment, employment assistance, and housing support.
Future research should continue to examine the mechanisms linking mental health, psychosocial factors, and criminal justice involvement among veterans. The authors recommend incorporating comprehensive, multi-item measures of justice involvement to better capture the frequency, type, and severity of legal system contact. Additionally, the use of administrative records related to criminal justice involvement could help reduce potential self-report bias. Longitudinal studies are particularly needed to clarify the temporal relationships among these factors and to identify critical windows for prevention and intervention. Such research would provide a deeper understanding of how risk factors evolve over time and how they can be effectively addressed.
In summary, this study highlights the importance of considering both shared and gender-specific pathways when identifying veterans at risk for justice involvement. The distinct risk profiles for women and men suggest that a one-size-fits-all approach is insufficient for addressing the complex needs of the veteran population. Integrated approaches that address substance use, suicide risk, housing instability, and emotional regulation are essential for reducing criminal justice system involvement. By tailoring interventions to the specific risk factors identified in this study, healthcare providers and policymakers can better support veterans during their transition to civilian life and promote long-term well-being and stability.
Subject of Research: Gender-specific correlates of post-deployment criminal justice involvement among Post-9/11 veterans
Article Title: Gender differences in criminal justice system involvement and associations with post-deployment factors among Post-9/11 veterans
Article References: Naganuma-Carreras, J., Collazo, E., Livingston, N., Kearns, J., Sager, J., Lee, D., Keane, T., & Marx, B. (2026). Gender differences in criminal justice system involvement and associations with post-deployment factors among Post-9/11 veterans. Health & Justice, 14(1), Article 39. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40352-026-00432-1
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s40352-026-00432-1
Keywords: Post-9/11 veterans, Criminal justice involvement, Gender differences, Problematic anger, Alcohol use disorder, Post-deployment factors, Veteran women, Veteran men, Suicide attempt history, Post-deployment homelessness, Somatoform disorder, Mental health, Substance use, Psychosocial factors, Health and Justice, Veterans Health Administration, Criminal justice system, Gender-responsive interventions, Self-report measures, Cross-sectional study
Source: bioengineer.org



