Drawing on ten years of the Safety and Justice Challenge, Nida Abbasi, Senior Program Officer, explores lessons about data, sustainability, and equity that can help shape the future of criminal justice reform.
As the Safety and Justice Challenge (SJC) approaches its conclusion this year, we reflect and look forward to the future. The SJC was designed to reimagine and rebuild local criminal justice systems by safely reducing jail incarceration and racial disparities. Over the past decade, our network of 100 counties, cities, and states has collectively lowered jail populations while sharing solutions and building a supportive ecosystem for change.
Through the last ten years of progress, setbacks, and learningthree lessons stand out: the power of data, the importance of sustained change over quick wins, and the reality that equity does not happen by accident.
Using Data to Drive Change
Data is a compass for change. Many of the grants MacArthur made as part of the SJC emphasized rigorous data collection and analysis. Participating communities created dashboards that track why people enter the jail system, how long they stay, and whether they are re-arrested. This provides local leaders with the information they need to identify problems and develop effective solutions.
Data helped communities pinpoint gaps in services, expose weak points in the system, and shape reforms that improve public safety while also reducing the chance of recidivism.
Data is a compass for change.
Data is also a powerful tool for persuasion. It allows leaders to discuss the real-world impacts of criminal justice reforms based on evidence rather than ideology. For example, data from Illinois shows that both crime and jail populations declined after cash bail was eliminated, challenging persistent, but inaccurate, narratives about this reform.
Sustainable Change Matters More Than Quick Wins

In many SJC communities, that shift has occurred through weekly jail population reviews where leaders across various local agencies come together to resolve delays and consider individuals who could be safely released. These regular meetings have fostered crucial face-to-face communication and collaboration and embedded a reform-oriented mindset in the local criminal justice system.
Quick progress is not the goal.
Of course, none of this work happens without resources, and funding remains important to continue moving forward. From the initiative’s outset, participating communities developed sustainability plans that included efforts to secure local government funding or philanthropic support after the SJC concludes. Planning for the future gives reforms the best chance of withstanding challenges and enduring over time.
Equity Does Not Happen by Accident

In 2019, an assessment of the SJC’s strategy revealed that while participating communities were making progress in reducing overall jail populations, racial and ethnic disparities had not improved. In other words, simply reducing the number of people in jail did not automatically make the criminal justice system fairer.
When the people closest to the harm help shape solutions, reforms work for people rather than against them.
In response, we evolved our approach, making racial and ethnic equity central to the SJC. This has meant asking cities and counties to meaningfully integrate people directly impacted by the criminal justice system in designing equity-focused strategies. Across the initiative, individuals with lived experience are now more engaged through regular meetings, programming shaped by their input, and new fellowships aimed at easing the transition out of jail.
As the SJC concludes its work this year, we hope every participating community carries these lessons forward. Criminal justice reform does not happen by accident. It must be pursued deliberately, guided by the individuals and communities who know the system best. When the people closest to the harm help shape solutions, reforms work for people rather than against them, paving the way for safer, stronger, more flourishing futures for all.
We are working with an evaluation and learning partner on a full assessment of our Criminal Justice program’s Safety and Justice Challenge. We plan to share the findings in early 2027.
Source: www.macfound.org



