For months, researchers at McMaster University in Canada struggled to understand something. Some mice infected with the Zika virus developed severe neurological symptoms. Some lost control of their hind legs. Others became paralyzed. Then, seemingly overnight, the symptoms all but disappeared.
The scientists were baffled. Had something gone wrong with the experiment? Was the virus somehow failing to infect the animals?
Then they noticed something peculiar. Every mouse in the latest batch was female. When they brought the males back, so did the paralysis.
A new study suggests that the difference boils down to how the male and female immune system responded to the levels of Zika in their blood and brains. This effect, researchers say, could also be linked to the infamous “man flu.”
Same Amount, Different Outcome
For years, “man flu” has been a running joke: men supposedly turn minor infections into major medical emergencies, while women soldier on. But scientists have long known that male and female immune systems behave differently, and some infections really do affect the sexes differently. That raises an interesting question: could biology explain why the same virus sometimes makes one person much sicker than another?
Led by doctoral researcher Alexa Mansour and immunologist Ali Ashkar, the McMaster team decided to investigate the strange difference systematically.
They infected age-matched male and female mice with equal doses of Zikaa mosquito-borne virus best known for causing birth defects but also capable of triggering serious neurological complications.
Within seven days, the contrast was striking.
Many male mice developed weakness or paralysis in their hind legs. Most females escaped severe neurological symptoms, although some experienced mild weakness.

Both groups lost similar amounts of weight. Yet their neurological outcomes were dramatically different.
The obvious explanation was that females were simply better at fighting the virus. But when researchers measured infectious virus in the animals’ blood and brains, they found no significant difference between the sexes.
“Both the males and females were infected under the same conditions—they were nearly genetically identical, they were the exact same age and they were infected with the same virus taken from the same vial in equal amounts,” Ashkar said in a statement. “It made no sense for there to be such a huge difference in how the disease presented.”
If the females weren’t carrying less virus, what was protecting them?
When the Immune System Becomes the Enemy
An infection can hurt you in two ways. The pathogen can damage your tissues directly, or your immune system can become so aggressive that it starts causing damage of its own.
Unfortunately, the body can (and often does) overreact. This is particularly dangerous in the brain, where inflammation can disrupt delicate nerve tissue.
The scientists found that male and female mice had similar overall numbers of immune cells entering their brains. However, the types of cells differed.
Female mice had a greater proportion of CD4 T cells, which help coordinate immune defenses, and a smaller proportion of CD8 T cells, which can kill infected or damaged cells.
More importantly, they had fewer CD8 T cells carrying a marker called NKG2D. These cells can become dangerous bystanders, attacking tissue even without directly recognizing the virus.

The male mice also showed stronger inflammatory signals in their brains. Their immune response appeared to be turning a viral infection into a much more destructive neurological illness.
There was already a clue pointing in this direction. In a 2024 study, the same research group found that blocking NKG2D activity or depleting CD8 T cells could prevent Zika-related paralysis in mice.
So Does This Mean “Man Flu” Is Actually Real?

The study was carried on mice, but intriguingly, there’s also a striking human parallel. During Zika outbreaks in seven countries, studies reported that Guillain–Barré syndrome, a potentially paralyzing neurological disorder, occurred 28% more frequently among males than females.
Surely, the flu must do something similar to Zika and affect males more, right?
Not so fast, my guys.
There is growing evidence that biological sex can influence the severity of certain viral infections, including COVID-19 and influenza. But this doesn’t mean men invariably get sicker, or that every immune difference favors women.
This makes it a plausible hypothesis, but it’s far from proven. It does suggest, however, that researchers should investigate how sex-related differences in inflammation also help explain neurological complications in humans.
Ashkar has suggested that doctors should pay particular attention to inflammation in men with acute viral infections.
Sometimes, the most dangerous part of an infection isn’t just the invader. It’s the body’s attempt to fight back.
The study was published in The Journal of Infectious Diseases.
Source: www.zmescience.com





