I was in the vaunted, formal courtroom when the U.S. Supreme Court’s heard oral arguments last month in Department of the Air Force v. Prutehi Guahana case that originated in the federal district court for Guam. I spent nearly 20 years of my career helping to build the Supreme Court of the U.S. Virgin Islands from a brand-new institution to an established court of last resort, and I traveled to Washington, DC with lawyers from fellow territories of Guam, Puerto Rico, the Northern Mariana Islands, and American Samoa — plus those from Native American tribes.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s building is more than a workplace; it’s also a museum administered by the Office of the Curator with a wide variety of exhibits intended to educate the public. One prominent exhibit, “Pathways to the Supreme Court,” offers visitors a map of the United States that shows how cases reach our nation’s highest court. Arrows trace cases through trial and appellate courts before converting on a single destination: the Supreme Court.
I looked for the Supreme Court of the U.S. Virgin Islands on the map, but couldn’t find it. Nor could I find the supreme courts of Puerto Rico, Guam, or any of the other U.S. territories.
Territorial supreme courts are neither state courts nor federal courts, a principle established by the U.S. Supreme Court itself. It first held in 1970’s Fornaris v. Ridge Tool Company that it could not exercise jurisdiction to review decisions of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico under the statute allowing it to review decisions of federal courts of appeals. Shortly thereafter, the Court clarified in Calero-Toledo v. Pearson Yacht Leasing Company that it could review judgments of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico under a statute specific to the territorynot the statute authorizing its review of state supreme court decisions.
Congress also created special pathways for the U.S. Supreme Court to review decisions of the Supreme Court of the U.S. Virgin Islands and other territories. Yet, as with the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico, these territorial supreme courts were entirely absent from the exhibit. While a pathway exists in the law, the exhibit gives visitors no identifiable place to find it — or to make them aware that there are even territorial courts in our judicial system. Ironically, the inclusion in the exhibit of the four federal district courts that operate in the territories contributes to this misperception. After all, if the designers of the exhibit were thoughtful enough to depict the federal courts operating in the territories, then a layperson with no knowledge of territorial court systems must surely assume that territorial supreme courts are not included in the exhibit like state courts because they simply do not exist.
This, of course, promotes one of the most disturbing myths about the territories: that they are entirely under federal control, have unsophisticated legal systems, and cannot use local law to safeguard their own rights or assert themselves as a check against governmental overreach in the same way state supreme courts do on a daily basis.
Museums, of course, face many constraints and must often make difficult choices. The Supreme Court curator has limited room to physically display exhibits. Ultimately, the Supreme Court building is first and foremost a functioning courthouse and workplace for hundreds of employees. With space at a premium, perhaps the curator deliberately chose to keep things simple.
But a second exhibit suggests the missing territorial supreme courts are part of a broader problem. In a series of displays on the U.S. Constitution, a panel declares that “Article IV defines the relationship among states, and between the states and the federal government.” Again, there is no reference to the territories — even though the Territorial Clause is found in Article IV and includes the only mention of territories in the U.S. Constitution outside of the Prohibition Amendments.
The Territorial Clause is not some obscure provision. Its inclusion in the Constitution was a rare point of agreement between Federalists and Anti-Federalists and prevented the nascent republic from devolving into wars between the states over Western lands; the interpretation given to it by the Supreme Court in Dred Scottv. Sandford led the United States to civil war; and the Court’s rulings in the Insular Cases that not all the protections of the federal Bill of Rights extend to the territories continue to define the lives of nearly four million people living in the territories to this very day.
These two exhibits appear opposite each other and concern different subjects — Supreme Court statutory jurisdiction on one side and constitutional federalism on the other. Yet both present visitors with the same familiar picture: States on one side, the federal government on the other, and territories nowhere to be found.
To the Americans who live in a state, that picture seems complete. It tracks the civics lessons taught throughout the 50 states from early childhood. But for those who visit the Supreme Court building from a territory, it is yet one more example of the systemic neglect and cultural invisibility that makes them feel like an other within their own country.
The people of the territories learn from a young age that living in a state is not just the default through which every individual right or civic responsibility is grounded, but seemingly the only status that matters; if you do not live in a state, you are not even part of the conversation. And as those from the territories know all too well, the ineptitude of our governmental institutions to educate mainland Americans about the territories shifts the burden onto the people of the territories to explain and correct — a large-scale form of what psychologists refer to as weaponized incompetence.
The territories, of course, are not the only non-state polities absent from the Supreme Court’s civics lessons. The exhibits likewise completely omit tribal nations, whose legal status and relationship to the federal government and the Supreme Court differ in still more ways from both the states and the territories. Further absent is any mention of the court of last resort for the very jurisdiction where the Supreme Court building is physically located: the District of Columbia Court of Appealswhose status as the equivalent of a state supreme court for the federal district also raises many distinct legal questions. Like the territories, these governments and their courts equally deserve recognition in the hallowed halls of our nation’s highest court.
This year marks not just the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence but also the 125th anniversary of the first of the Insular Cases — perhaps the perfect time for the Office of the Curator to create a special exhibit on the Supreme Court and the legal history of the territories. As it stands, there is enough empty wall space on the “Pathways to the Supreme Court” exhibit to acknowledge territorial and tribal courts and the courts of the District of Columbia. Likewise, sufficient space exists on the “Article IV to VII” exhibit to add a sentence or two on the Territorial Clause. It should not take too much effort for the Supreme Court’s curator to provide a minimum level of recognition.
Anthony M. Ciolli is practicing faculty at St. Mary’s University School of Law. He was formerly the president of the Virgin Islands Bar Association and a special assistant to Hon. Rhys S. Hodge, chief justice of the Virgin Islands. The views expressed herein are solely his own and not those of the judicial branch of the Virgin Islands, the Virgin Islands Bar Association, or any of their officers or employees.
Source: statecourtreport.org



