In a newly unsealed 2012 document, a lawyer for Raymond “RC” Horsch wrote to the court that Horsch had exposed himself to a “great degree of danger” while cooperating with the federal government as an informant.
Judge Paul Diamond last week granted a motion filed by the Philadelphia Inquirer to lift the seal on previously secret judicial documents in Horsch’s drug trafficking case from 14 years ago.
Horsch, who died last year, is being investigated as a suspected serial killeraccording to numerous law enforcement sources with direct knowledge of the case.
Amy McHale was nervous taking the stand. She was testifying in a sentencing hearing for her estranged husband, the late Raymond “R.C.” Horsch.
“When I met Ray, I was at a really low point in my life,” McHale is quoted as telling the court, according to a transcript of the June 2012 hearing unsealed Tuesday.
Horsch was incarcerated in the Federal Detention Center in Philadelphia’s Chinatown neighborhood. He had been locked up on drug trafficking offenses since 2009. Other unsealed documents show Horsch was being treated for macular degeneration, high blood pressure and arrhythmia.
“He’s done some bad things, but he, deep down, is a really good person,” McHale is quoted as saying. “He wants to help people. And I don’t know if he always goes about it the right way, but he helped me tremendously.”
Horsch faced the possibility of the rest of his life in federal custody for drug trafficking offenses. But his attorney secured a deal in what’s known as a plea agreement. Records unsealed last week described Horsch’s cooperation and the information he provided to the feds on drug trafficking and crimes against children as credible and reliable.
In other records, Jerome Brown, his attorney, said Horsch, in his cooperation as a federal informant, subjected himself to a “great degree of danger.”
McHale offered a glimpse into her life with Horsch.
“I met him the way he’s met many of the other girls,” she said. “I was out there on the street doing drugs. He took me in. Encouraged me in every way to get help for my addiction.”
Horsch, whose May 2025 death has left a towering cloud of mystery, is under investigation as a suspected serial killer.
At the 2012 hearing, Brown argued for leniency.
“I know that [Raymond] also wants to be able to get out so that he can try to give his son [Eugene] some type of foundation,” the transcript reads. “Because he’s not going to be around forever. … Basically, he sits in his bunk all day long. And he’s a bright guy, but he’s got — you know, he’s a little bipolar.”
The attorney also presented a letter to the court from former Philadelphia Mayor John Street. It alleges Street believed Raymond Horsch was doing good on Kensington streets.
The transcript quotes Brown as telling the court about the letter: “…I don’t have it with me, he even had a letter from Mayor Street that said, if you — don’t arrest him because he’s doing something good here.”
Brown went on to say, according to the transcript: “Just because he goes up to these women, he’s not doing it for purposes of soliciting.”
Street called the letter “fake news” and said he had “absolutely no recollection of anything like this.”
Brown told CBS News Philadelphia that, with all the time that’s passed, he could not possibly remember any letter.
Raymond Horsch is alleged to have preyed on an unknown number of women, using those struggling with addiction in Kensington, to lure them to his home at 417 W. Chew Ave. That information is according to law enforcement sources and multiple interviews CBS News Philadelphia has conducted over the past few months.
Midway through the 2012 hearing, Horsch was given an opportunity to address the court.
“Thank you, Your Honor,” he said as quoted in the transcript. “Just as succinctly as possible, it’s been pointed out that I’ve done some very bad things in my life. I’d just like to point out that I’ve also done some good things. And if I have any time left, I’d like to spend that trying to do some good things to offset the bad things that I’ve done. I’d like to be able to spend time with my son, and I certainly accept total responsibility for everything that I’ve done. I’m very ashamed of myself, and I guess that’s all I can think to say. I’d just like the opportunity to tip the scales in the other direction a little bit, if I can.”
Horsch was granted a significant break, counting time served.
“Mr. Horsch, and in many respects, it is almost tragic,” Judge Barclay Surrick is quoted in the transcript. “You are a brilliant person. You have incredible talent. You have used that talent, and I don’t think there was any need for you to get involved in the criminal activity that’s reflected in the pre-sentence investigation report or the criminal activity that I have to impose a sentence that’s going to protect the public.”
At least seven women have been tied to the Olney home referred to as the “house of horrors.” It’s alleged Horsch used a chemically destructive process known as “wet cremation” to destroy human remains, according to law enforcement sources close to the investigation. Police have described watching Horsch strangle a woman in one of a million videos and photos recovered from the home.
No human remains have been found at the house, but detectives have looked for evidence of wet cremationwhich is when a mix of chemicals is used to break down human remains, law enforcement sources with direct knowledge of the case told CBS News Philadelphia. Chemicals and pipes have been removed from the property during the investigation.
“It is my sincere hope that the public really doesn’t need to be protected from you anymore,” Surrick is quoted as saying. “I’m going to place you on supervised release for a period of five years. That will give the government the opportunity to keep track of you. And if you get out, and you start engaging in the kind of conduct that got you here, you’re going to end up back in jail.”
McHale, Horsch’s former wife, did not elaborate in her testimony on what happened to their marriage or the other women Raymond encountered.
“I don’t know what happened to many of the other girls, but I am able to live a full life now because of Raymond,” McHale said.
Amy McHale disappeared in 2016. She hasn’t been seen since.
Source: www.cbsnews.com



