• Home  
  • Q&A: What can you do when holiday turkey talk veers into politics?
Q&A: What can you do when holiday turkey talk veers into politics?
- Politics

Q&A: What can you do when holiday turkey talk veers into politics?

Holiday dinner tables can serve up controversial conversations, like the superiority of canned cranberry sauce over homemade or the exclusion of oysters from turkey dressing. But with midterm election results just a few weeks old, political topics are likely to fall onto plates, too, straining even the closest relationships and threatening Thanksgiving joy. We asked Rachel

Holiday dinner tables can serve up controversial conversations, like the superiority of canned cranberry sauce over homemade or the exclusion of oysters from turkey dressing.

But with midterm election results just a few weeks old, political topics are likely to fall onto plates, too, straining even the closest relationships and threatening Thanksgiving joy.

We asked Rachel Wahl, a professor in the University of Virginia’s School of Education and Human Developmentfor some holiday advice for people who find themselves conversing about politics – whether they want to or not – and her thoughts on when those conversations can help or hurt and what it means to connect across political differences.

Wahl studies democracy, political disagreement and how people navigate deeply held differences. Her research spans college campuses, civic organizations, police-community partnerships and more.

She also directs the Good Life Political Project through UVA’s Karsh Institute of Democracy, where she is an inaugural faculty fellow. Her new book, “Keeping Our Enemies Closer: Political Dialogue in Polarized Democracies,” examines what happens when people with fundamentally different views sit down to talk.

Q. How do we know when it’s worth engaging in a difficult conversation, and when it’s better not to?

A. Trying to understand an opposing view can sometimes be harmful for the listener, if they feel threatened or dehumanized. For this reason, I do not think that anyone has an obligation to listen.

It is often not clear-cut, though. In “Keeping Our Enemies Closer,” I tell the story of Jane, a liberal, gay woman who was in conversation with a conservative, evangelical Christian man. She felt deeply shaken by his opposition to her marriage rights. At the same time, it was meaningful to her that he treated her with respect in the conversation.

When I followed up with the man years later, I learned that he had never stopped thinking about their conversation. He had actually shifted his views on marriage rights, though not necessarily solely as a result of talking to Jane. But Jane would not know that her interaction had any impact. Dialogue is often ambivalent in this way.

Q. Would our political division be less if we talked to one another more?

A. Dialogue can help people become more sympathetic toward those with whom they disagree. But that doesn’t necessarily mean they will change their minds about politics.

So, it’s true that dialogue can deepen our understanding, compassion and respect for people who disagree with us. But those outcomes aren’t inevitable, and we shouldn’t assume that talking will lead to agreement.

I hope people will reconsider the assumption that conversation must persuade someone (in order) to be useful for democracy. Understanding can be surprisingly productive.

At the same time, I hope people will not valorize dialogue as the solution to all problems or the only legitimate means of political communication. Protest, voting and all other tools of democracy are essential for political and social change.

Q. If conversation isn’t necessarily about changing someone’s mind, what makes a difficult political conversation worthwhile?

A. Some of the best outcomes occur when people develop a better understanding of what precisely they disagree about and why. They may begin a conversation assuming that others are misinformed, irrational or immoral, but dialogue helps them uncover the life experiences and values that make sense of others’ views.

Understanding the deeper reasons for our disagreements can make other people appear far more relatable and sympathetic. This, in turn, can diminish support for politicians who stoke violence and policies that disenfranchise the other side. It can also make us more willing to work with people productively, if the opportunity arises.

Q. For someone who has stopped talking with a friend, family member or neighbor because of political disagreement, what’s a realistic first step toward reengagement?

A. Start by reconnecting with the person outside of their political identities, as these do not wholly define who we are. Once the connection is revived, ask questions motivated by curiosity: “What worries you most about our country? What gives you the most hope? When did you first start caring about that issue? Have your views on it changed for any reason?”

Source: news.virginia.edu

About Us

Toolq Media Is a Global News Platform Covering the Latest Developments and Breaking Stories from Around The World, Including World News, Business, Finance, Technology, Health, Politics, Science, Entertainment, Sports, and More.

Toolq

Toolq @2026. All Rights Reserved.