KEY INSIGHTS
- The threat is internal: Israel retains overwhelming military superiority, yet its devastating response to 7 October now endangers the Jewish State more than Hamas.
- Legitimacy is draining away: Public opinion in Europe and North America has turned against Israel, and even younger diaspora Jews are distancing themselves from it.
- Every alternative fails the test: A single binational state invites bloodshed, “Greater Israel” breaches international law and justice, and confederation presumes a trust that does not yet exist.
- Partition remains the least bloody path: As Amos Oz argued, the two-state solution is the only realistic route to lasting security for Israelis and Palestinians alike.
- Both frontrunners reject it: Gadi Eisenkot and Benjamin Netanyahu oppose Palestinian statehood on security grounds, yet security bought at the expense of Palestinian rights is unattainable.
On 7 October 2023, several thousand Hamas fighters and their associates breached Israel’s border with Gaza. During the short-lived incursion, more than 1,200 people, mostly civilians, were killed, while 251 were abducted to Gaza. According to an independent commission, many of the victims of the Hamas-led attack had been subjected to sexual and gender-based violence or torture.
Despite the complacency and security lapses that enabled Hamas to carry out its unprecedented assault, Israel continues to enjoy overwhelming military superiority over its adversaries, both states and non-state actors. If countries such as Egypt and Syria, heavily armed by the Soviet Union, once posed an existential threat to the Jewish State, there is a growing consensus that the most serious threats now facing Israel—even allowing for the eliminationist rhetoric of Iran’s clerical leaders and Iran’s alleged nuclear ambitions—are internal in character. As the Israeli novelist and peace activist Amos Oz warned in a late essay, “Dreams Israel Should Let Go of Soon”, Israel is in danger of destroying itself.
A Prisoner of Its Own History
For Israelis, as for many, perhaps most, Jews in the diaspora, 7 October was not “simply” a bloody and audacious act of terrorism. The massacre of several hundred defenceless Jews, including women, children, and the elderly, evoked memories of the Holocaust, which is almost certainly what Hamas had intended. This may explain, at least in part, the scale and ferocity of Israel’s military response.
Israel has sought to justify its ongoing military campaign in Gaza, launched in the wake of 7 October, as the only means of dismantling the “terror infrastructure and capabilities” of Hamas and of the other militant Islamist groups that remain active in the territory. However, the operation—which has inflicted immense suffering on Gaza’s civilian population while conspicuously failing to dislodge Hamas—has been widely condemned as unlawful, including by leading international lawyers in Israel. A report issued jointly by the World Bank, the European Union, and the United Nations in spring 2026 lays bare the extent of the humanitarian crisis:
> Over 1.9 million Palestinians in the Gaza Strip have been internally displaced to locations inside of the Gaza Strip, many of them multiple times over; and over 1.2 million people—almost 60 percent of Gaza Strip’s population—have lost their homes. Extensive damage to water, sanitation, and waste management infrastructure, a lack of critical resources to operate and maintain the remaining infrastructure, and poor hygiene conditions and food insecurity have left the entire population of the Gaza Strip at risk of disease outbreaks.
Ironically, Israel’s devastating military response to 7 October almost certainly represents a far greater threat to the Jewish State than Hamas’s fitful campaign of terror. The humanitarian toll of Israel’s campaign has severely strained the country’s relations with previously friendly Western governments, while Israel’s image across much of the global south has been badly damaged. Even in Europe and North America, public opinion has gradually turned against Israel, due principally to the scale of civilian casualties, credible reports of an ongoing humanitarian crisis, and inflammatory statements by far-right Israeli ministers, including Itamar Ben-Gvir, calling for the wholesale resettlement of Gaza’s Palestinian population. Many younger Jews in North America are beginning to distance themselves from Israel.
An underlying shift in “progressive” political attitudes in the West—particularly apparent in universities and on the Left—has contributed to the gradual delegitimisation of Israel and the elevation of Palestine into the pre-eminent global symbol of thwarted justice. A preference for categorical moral judgements over nuance and complexity and a somewhat selective reading of history have played a part in this process. The influence of ideas frequently identified as left-wing antisemitism has also been a factor. However, it would be absurd to discount the impact on public opinion around the world of the unconscionable scale of civilian suffering in Gaza, and the plight of Palestinians in the West Bank, who face escalating violence and intimidation from “hilltop youths” aided and abetted by elements of the most right-wing government in Israel’s history.
Two Apartments in a Single House
Amos Oz believed that justice and political pragmatism alike demand the creation of a sovereign Palestinian state alongside Israel. As Oz expressed it: “[t]here is no escape from dividing up this little house into two even smaller apartments”.
The so-called two-state solution, which was proposed by the UN General Assembly in November 1947 and which seemed on the brink of realisation more than 40 years later, with the conclusion of the Oslo Accords, has fallen out of favour. Although Simon Schama and other scholars emphatically reject such arguments, growing numbers on the Left and in the academy dismiss Israel as illegitimate and as a settler colonial state. For this expanding constituency, a single democratic state comprising Palestinians and Jews, stretching “from the river to the sea”, is the only acceptable political outcome.
Like many on the Left, particularly in Europe and North America, influential voices on the far right of Israeli politics also condemn the partition of Palestine after the Second World War. Driven variously by religious or extreme nationalist sentiment, they envision a “Greater Israel” encompassing, at a minimum, the whole of what is now Israel-Palestine. A third and smaller constituency, which includes moderate Palestinians and Israelis, advocates some form of confederation between Israel and a future Palestinian state.
After more than a century of mutual fear and mistrust and repeated cycles of violence—culminating in the slaughter of Jewish civilians on 7 October and Israel’s crushing military response—a single democratic state encompassing roughly equal numbers of Jews and Palestinians would almost certainly be a prescription for chaos and bloodshed. On the other hand, the idea of “Greater Israel”—a hard-right fantasy of Jewish sovereignty over the whole of Israel-Palestine—is unethical, unfeasible, and contrary to established principles of international law, including the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination.
By contrast, the notion of a confederation of Jewish and Palestinian states, although liberal and progressive in spirit, is quite simply utopian in the present circumstances. Until Israelis and Palestinians have demonstrated at least a minimum level of mutual trust, an ability to work together in pursuit of common goals, and the willingness to act decisively against disruptive elements within their respective communities, it is hard to see how a confederation could work in practice.
For all its inherent limitations and despite the enormous practical difficulties involved, the two-state solution remains the only realistic option, and the one that is likely to result in “the least bloody scenario”. It may not satisfy every descendant of Palestinians forced to flee their homes in what is now Israel during the fighting that erupted in 1948-49. It may provoke outrage among Israeli Jews on the Religious Right who believe that Scripture gives the Jewish people an absolute, God-given right to “Greater Israel”. Yet, as Professor Fania Oz-Salzberger—Amos Oz’s daughter—noted recently, the two-state solution offers “a practical horizon for coexistence, and a life raft for both nations”. Writing in Foreign Affairs, Andrew P. Miller, formerly Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Israeli-Palestinian Affairs in the Biden Administration, also calls on Israel to resurrect the “much-maligned two-state solution” and to end its “expansionist policies” in the West Bank or face a possibly irreversible and catastrophic loss of American support.
At the time of writing, the outcome of the recent elections held in Israel remains unclear. No single party commands a majority in the Knesset, Israel’s legislature. However, Gadi Eisenkot, leader of the centrist Yashar party, enjoys significant support amongst Knesset members and has been tasked by President Herzog with forming a coalition government. Unlike Yair Golan, leader of the Democrats party, neither of the leading contenders for the post of prime minister, Gadi Eisenkot and Benjamin Netanyahu, favours the two-state solution, essentially on the grounds that a radicalised Palestinian state would threaten Israel’s security.
Yet, as Amos Oz understood, long-term security for Israel cannot be achieved at the expense of the legitimate rights of Palestinians. That would be morally unacceptable and—as the carnage of 7 October suggests—virtually impossible to achieve. “There must be compromise between Israel and Palestine”, Oz concluded. “There must be two states.”
Source: www.socialeurope.eu



