The release of the documentary series Crime and Punishment in America this week is giving stations, educators and the film’s creators an opportunity to spark reflection and conversation about the state of the country’s criminal justice system.
The four-part series, which premiered Monday on PBS stations, explores how the U.S. has struggled to contend with the root causes of crime, the purpose of punishment and the meaning of justice. Screenings and panel discussions at stations, schools and even prisons are bringing diverse perspectives to the subject, featuring insights from historians, corrections officers, previously incarcerated people and victims of crime.
“This is a polarizing topic,” says director Lynn Novick, who previously worked with Ken Burns on The Vietnam War, Hemingway and Prohibition. Burns is EP of Crime and Punishment in Americaalong with Sam Pollard.
“We tried to make a film and tell the story in a way that gives room for people to disagree and have radically different experiences and perspectives,” Novick says. “We hope to give our viewers an opportunity for a different kind of conversation and maybe even some progress on issues that are difficult.”
In the lead-up to the broadcast, Novick and her production company Skiff Mountain Films worked alongside criminal justice organizations on Crime and Punishment in America events. Just Trust, a nonprofit organization focused on criminal justice reform, has partnered on screenings with 14 stations. Represent Justice, which uses storytelling to help reform the justice and prison system, will conduct outreach programming after the broadcast and into May 2027.
Educating the public about the history and impact of the criminal justice system can fuel reform of policing, prison conditions and sentencing practices, Novick says. “A lot of what happens is behind walls, in courtrooms and police stations, so people who are fortunate enough to have never had anyone they care about incarcerated don’t know what’s going on,” she says.
Stations have framed post-screening discussions by curating clips from the series with local relevance and inviting a wide variety of participants. For a preview Oct. 27, KQED screened an excerpt from the series about the 1993 kidnapping and murder of 12-year-old Polly Klaas in Petaluma, Calif. Klaas’ murder fueled support for the state’s Three Strikes Law, which dramatically increased prison sentences for people convicted of a third felony after two previous serious or violent felony convictions, contributing to prison overcrowding.
After the screening, Novick joined a panel featuring correctional wellness advocate Stephen B. Walker; Jess Nichol, Klaas’ sister and an advocate for crime victims and survivors; and Rahsaan Thomas, a consulting producer for Crime and Punishment in America who was incarcerated for 22 years. During the conversation, Thomas addressed the idea of redemption and said that he wanted to prove people are capable of change.
Novick remembers that Thomas said he wanted to talk to people who don’t trust him and didn’t think he should be there. “I want them to see who I am right now,” he said. Putting previously incarcerated individuals at the heart of discussions and introducing them and their stories deepens audiences’ engagement with Crime and Punishment in America’s themes of rehabilitation, punishment and injustice, says Novick.
Ryan Davis, head of events and experiences at KQED, said he hopes that the 127 attendees at KQED’s screening gained a “meaningful understanding of some of the contradictions at the heart of the American criminal justice system, its histories of racial subjugation and unequal application of the law, and its competing visions of punishment and rehabilitation.”
Showcasing community views
Cherri Gregg, co-host of the new show Studio 2 on WHYY in Philadelphia, said she wanted her station’s screening to explore how crime is politicized. She hosted a panel discussion Nov. 12 that included Novick, Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner and Felix Rosado, co-founder and executive director of Let’s Circle Up, a nonprofit that teaches restorative justice in prisons and communities.
“Most people are not inherently criminals,” says Gregg. “I want to look at the mindset of people who commit crime and focus on the circumstances that led to the crime, because a lot of the root cause is scarcity, poverty, abuse and so many other things. What circumstances made the person think committing crime made sense? Because crime does not represent them as an entire person.”
GPB decided to host its screening Nov. 30 so attendees would have time to watch the series. “We want people to watch it at home, think about it, then come and be part of this conversation,” says Emmalee Hacksaw, GPB’s chief development and engagement officer. “Then maybe they can go watch it again.”
Hacksaw wanted GPB’s Crime and Punishment in America event to focus on the history of Georgia’s criminal justice system. Participants will include Pulitzer Prize–winning author Douglas Blackmon; Carl Suddler, an associate professor of history at Emory University; and Sara Totonchi, a coordinator with the Justice Fund of Georgia, who will discuss the everyday realities of incarcerated people.
“We want this to be a very local conversation,” Hacksaw says. “The intention behind all of our community engagement is to take national content but make it unique and interesting for people in Georgia.”
Meanwhile, Vegas PBS invited Geoff Schumacher, a VP at the city’s Mob Museum, to its preview screening Nov. 1 to talk about how organized crime shaped Las Vegas. And Nashville PBS devoted an October episode of its talk show A Slice of the Community to the question “Does criminal punishment keep us safe?”
“We always wanted to explore crime and punishment in America, but the documentary gave us a great opportunity to do that,” says Jerome Moore, the show’s host. “We wanted to take a slightly different approach to the documentary. We didn’t want to focus on the punishment side. We wanted to ask, what does safety mean to people in America?”
‘A profound and intense experience’
Since August, prisons across the country, including Rikers Island, Sing Sing, the San Quentin Rehabilitation Center and the Washington Corrections Center for Women, have screened highlight reels of Crime and Punishment in America.

Novick said she wanted to host screenings in prisons to include incarcerated people in conversations. Other panelists have included poet Dwayne Betts and Daniel Martuscello, commissioner of the New York State Department of Correction. Jess Nichol joined Annie Nichol, also a sister of Polly Klaas, on a visit to San Quentin, where Novick says they “spoke beautifully about a more humane criminal justice system, approaches that don’t focus on vengeance and punishment, and how healing it was for them to be there.”
“Watching victims, officers and someone who is incarcerated have dialogue, hear each other, and talk about what is wrong, what could be fixed, and their hope for the future of the justice system … has been a really profound and intense experience,” says Novick.
Represent Justice has begun organizing screenings with K–12 schools, colleges and universities and equipping teachers with resources developed by PBS LearningMedia. “We need to target young folks and educational spaces so we can have a big impact downstream,” says Represent Justice CEO Daniel Forkkio.
Showing clips of Crime and Punishment in America in primary and secondary classes and encouraging students to watch the entire series is vital because the documentary depicts aspects of the justice system and its history that aren’t taught in schools, Forkkio says. “We want kids to understand and form their own beliefs about crime and punishment in the United States and the justice system,” he says.
Represent Justice will also take the series into law, journalism and public policy classes at colleges and universities to teach future journalists, prosecutors, elected officials and public defenders about the complexity of criminal justice. “This is an excellent opportunity for people to define and understand the way their future profession, civic action and views intersect with the justice system, a system that impacts everybody in the U.S.,” says Forkkio. “It’s really, really important that we attack the narratives of the justice system, the dehumanization that’s part of the justice system, and the overall philosophy of punishment around the justice system.”
“I hope people take action legislatively. I hope universities and law schools will deepen their involvement,” says Forkkio. “That’s the beauty of a series like this. It shows there’s a role everyone can play to raise awareness, create conversation and educate people on criminal justice in their communities.”
Novick says she’s already been heartened by the responses to Crime and Punishment in America, with viewers telling her after screenings that the film made them think about the topic from different perspectives.
“I’ve had correction officers tell me they’d never thought about what victims want and vice versa,” she says. “People have been telling me they’ve learned a lot and couldn’t look away, which are always great notes for any filmmaker.”
Source: current.org



