David Jones is deeply in debt, with its liabilities revealed so far reaching almost half a billion dollars.
The retailer owes at least $180 million to suppliers, more than $200 million to lenders and more than $10 million to its own staff.
The debts were revealed at the almost two-hour first creditors’ meeting for the embattled department store, which was placed into voluntary administration earlier this month.
It has already been announced that the receiver will close 19 of the retailer’s 38 stores by the end of 2027.
Administrators are now trying to find a buyer for David Jones to keep the legacy brand alive.
McGrathNicol’s role as voluntary administrator is to tally the company’s debts and possibly find a buyer to recoup cash for entities owed money, such as suppliers and landlords.
The retailer’s key secured lender, Hilco, will be first in line to claw back money. It has appointed a receiver, FTI Consulting, to David Jones and now controls its day-to-day operations.
The 188-year-old department store’s collapse came after negotiations broke down with Scentre Group, the owner of key shopping centre chain Westfield, which confirmed David Jones was behind on its rent since September.
Supplier frustrations
David Jones has more than 1,000 suppliers. (ABC News: Fletcher Yeung)
A long list of woes is blamed for David Jones’s collapse, including difficult trading as the cost of living bites, competition from online retail, and an “unsustainable” business model, McGrathNicol said.
The meeting, attended by just under 500 people, heard from suppliers of everything from clothing to truffles, with anxious brand owners asking questions about when, if ever, they would see debts paid.
“It has become pretty apparent to others in the market that some suppliers, specifically the larger ones, were given preferential treatment,” one supplier told the meeting.
Store suppliers have told ABC News they have been struggling to get invoices paid for months. Some are owed more than $100,000.
David Jones has more than 1,000 suppliers, 6,000 employees and a similar number of concession staff, all impacted by the collapse.
The main retail union, the Shop, Distributive and Allied Employee’s Association (SDA) confirmed after the meeting that 1,689 direct jobs were on the line and only 170 positions have been offered redeployment.
NSW branch secretary Bernie Smith said the union expected further job losses from staff employed by concessions, but did not have exact numbers.
Unsecured creditors, which include suppliers, are lower on the list to be repaid, behind employees and secured creditors Hilco, Anchorage Capital Partners (ACP) and Commonwealth Bank.
David Jones is due to close half of its stores. (ABC News)
One supplier asked if for a possible range of how much they might receive to the dollar, which McGrathNicol administrator Matthew Hutton said it was too soon to know the value or an exact timeline.
He said there were “too many variables”, including not having engaged with enough bidders to know the value, pre-Christmas trade and the upcoming store closures, adding they might not know the potential return to creditors until mid to late January.
Brands that have been selling stock in David Jones stores within their own sub-leases under concession arrangements, also asked about whether they would see sales revenue repaid.
“If David Jones was to go into liquidation can partners take their stock back prior to the company being liquidated?” asked one brand owner, with McGrathNicol confirming this was the case.
Administrators also confirmed some brands had pulled out of David Jones since the administration, but this was “limited” and the receivers now controlling the stores were experiencing record sales.
Several suppliers expressed frustration with a lack of correspondence from FTI regarding stock levels and sales since November 5.
Julie Mathers left the meeting frustrated. (ABC News: Fletcher Yeung)
The co-owner of a baby clothing brand that supplied David Jones said she left the virtual meeting emotional.
“I feel angry about it. I feel it’s unfair and unjust,” Snuggle Hunny’s Julie Mathers told ABC News.
She said they could not see how suppliers like Snuggle Hunny would get back debts even if a buyer was found.
“I just can’t see how we’ll get anything.“
David Jones directors enacted ‘safe harbour’ provisions
The administrators also confirmed David Jones directors had enacted “safe harbour” provisions, a legal provision under the Corporations Act, which allows directors to try and trade a company out of financial distress, but avoid personal liability for insolvent trading.
Insolvent trading is when a company or person cannot pay debts when they are due.
“We understand the directors had engaged directors to assist them with safe harbour,” administrators said.
“We are aware they were in safe harbour, but we don’t know the date this commenced.”
Insolvency expert Ginette Muller told ABC News it suggests David Jones has possibly been insolvent or on the verge of insolvency for some time.
“Safe harbour means that the directors don’t want to be sued for insolvent trading. It can suggest that the company has been insolvent trading,” she said.
Administrators are in the process of applying for an extension for the second creditors meeting through the courts, and do not expect that to occur until March 2027.
McGrathNicol has previously talked up interest in the business, with its partner describing interest from buyers as “extraordinary”.
Secured lender Hilco will have a majority say on a buyer, meaning a new owner could be announced before March.
At the end of the meeting an inspection taskforce was compiled for the administration, with it including representatives from well-known brands like Ralph Lauren, Estee Lauder and key landlords GPT and Scentre.
The taskforce acts as liaisons representing the interest of everyone from suppliers to landlords and staff, set up due to the large amount of creditors owed money.
Loading…
Source: www.abc.net.au



