- The Supreme Court allows SMEs to correct a bonus that had already been communicated to the staff
- When can companies correct incentives without negotiating
- What self-employed workers and SMEs should take into account before reducing a bonus
- Companies cannot unilaterally change the bonus rules
Las SMEs Those who have incentive systems for their employees have a little more room to correct certain errors in the calculation of bonuses. And the Supreme Court has established that a company can rectify downwards an incentive that it had already communicated to its staff when it detects a error in the data used to calculate the objectives, without this action necessarily having to be processed as a substantial modification of the working conditions.
The ruling, handed down on October 13, 2026, distinguishes between changing the rules that determine how much a worker charges for their results and correct a specific amount which had been calculated incorrectly. The difference is important for self-employed workers with employees and SMEs that use commissions, bonuses or variable remuneration to encourage the activity of their teams.
The Supreme Court allows SMEs to correct a bonus that had already been communicated to the staff
The case analyzed by the Supreme Court affected Regus Management Spain, a company that had a variable remuneration system for your operations staff. Thus, the incentives depended on the economic results of the teams and were calculated quarterly, with three levels of achievement of objectives.
In January 2025, the company communicated its objectives for the first quarter. Once that period ended, on April 25, it informed the workers of the level of compliance achieved and the bonus that corresponded to them. However, a few weeks later, on May 16, it reported that it had detected a error in net income used as a reference to calculate the objectives.
The company claimed it had left out certain service revenues, causing targets to be set lower than they should have been. By correcting the data, several teams moved from an intermediate level of compliance to the minimum. The result was a bonus reduction which, for many workers, meant earning half or even less than what they had initially been informed of.
It was then that UGT presented a collective dispute, to which CCOO joined. The National Court agreed with the unions in September 2025 and considered that the company had carried out a substantial modification of working conditions without following the corresponding procedure. The company appealed and the Supreme Court has revoked that resolution.
When can companies correct incentives without negotiating
The key to ruling 829/2026 is that the company had not changed its general variable remuneration policy. It had not established new objectives for the following quarters nor modified the conditions that determined the collection of incentives. He had corrected the amount corresponding to a specific period after detecting an error in the income used to make the calculations.
The Supreme Court considers that, taking into account the importance of the rectification and its limited temporal scope, it was a accidental modification and not a substantial modification of working conditions. Therefore, the company did not have to resort to the procedure provided for in article 41 of the Workers’ Statute.
This article regulates the relevant changes in certain working conditions, including the remuneration system and the amount of salary. Because when a company intends to introduce a substantial modification For economic, technical, organizational or production reasons, it must comply with legal requirements. But if the measure is collective in nature, it must also open a period of consultation with the workers’ representation.
The ruling allows us to differentiate, therefore, two situations. one thing is correct a specific calculation because wrong data has been used and it is quite another matter to stably modify the criteria with which commissions or bonuses are calculated. This second decision may constitute a substantial modification and require the corresponding procedure.
What self-employed workers and SMEs should take into account before reducing a bonus
Thus, the statement offers a reference for small businesses that use incentives linked to sales, productivity or achievement of objectives. However, it does not imply a general authorization to revise downwards any amount communicated to the workforce. The company must be able to justify that it is a spot correction and not a hidden change in salary conditions.
To avoid labor conflicts, businesses should take extreme caution when designing and implementing their variable compensation systems:
Define in writing the objectives and calculation formulas. Workers must know what results will be taken into account, how they will be measured and what amount they can receive based on their compliance.
Keep the documentation that justifies any rectification. If an error is detected, the company should identify the incorrect data, explain how it affected the initial calculation, and document the correction.
Distinguish between correcting a quarter and changing system rules. If the intention is to permanently modify the objectives, percentages or criteria for collecting incentives, it is not enough to present the decision as an accounting correction.
Companies cannot unilaterally change the bonus rules
However, it must also be taken into account that article 26 of the Workers’ Statute establishes that the salary structure is determined by the collective bargaining or, failing that, the individual contract. And among the salary supplements Those linked to the work performed and the situation or results of the company are considered. Therefore, incentives and bonuses are part of the remuneration and must adjust to the conditions that regulate their receipt.
If an SME wants to change the variable remuneration system in a relevant and permanent way, it must analyze whether it is facing a substantial modification and comply with the requirements of article 41. However, the Supreme Court’s ruling provides legal certainty in a specific case: it allows distinguishing a one-off rectification from a structural change in salary conditions. For small businesses, the main lesson is that they can correct proven errors in the calculation of an incentive without having to automatically activate a substantial modification procedure, but they must justify the rectification and respect the rules agreed upon with their staff.
Source: www.autonomosyemprendedor.es



