UK-based asset manager Asset Value Investors (AVI) has moved to block South Korea’s Daou Technology’s plan to acquire new shares in JoongAng Ilbo. AVI, which holds about a 2.2% stake in Daou Technology, sent a public letter on the 16th demanding the company withdraw its 190 billion won (approximately $142.4 million) investment in JoongAng Ilbo and use the funds for share buybacks and cancellation instead.
In the letter to Daou Technology’s board, AVI urged the formation of a special committee composed of independent directors and a review of the transaction from scratch with outside advice. It also demanded that the board publicly respond to its concerns by no later than the 30th of this month. AVI raised three main issues: the unclear basis for the acquisition price, the lack of overlap between the newspaper business and Daou Technology’s core operations, and the possibility that the deal could widen the stock’s discount.
Daou Technology’s board convened on the 4th and resolved to acquire 38 million new JoongAng Ilbo shares for 190 billion won. The payment date is the 23rd of next month. The total investment by the consortium, formed together with Saramin, CJ, and Shinsegae, amounts to 520 billion won (approximately $389.7 million), with Daou Technology and Saramin set to acquire a 47.27% stake in JoongAng Ilbo for 261.4 billion won (approximately $195.9 million). JoongAng Ilbo entered a workout process in July and has since undergone a sale procedure via a third-party allotment rights offering led by its main creditor bank, Hana Bank.
AVI pointed out that the consortium’s 520 billion won acquisition amount far exceeds the 300 billion to 400 billion won range of competitive bids previously reported in the media, and that the reason must be explained transparently. Given that JoongAng Ilbo posted a net loss of about 92 billion won (approximately $68.9 million) in the first half of this year alone, AVI argued the company should disclose its valuation methodology and assumptions, post-investment equity value, expected and minimum returns, and investment recovery period. It also demanded disclosure of whether payment guarantees provided for affiliate debts will remain after the transaction.
AVI also questioned the business synergies. It said there is no overlap between Daou Technology—whose main businesses are financial IT, groupware, and messaging—and the newspaper business. AVI stated flatly that diversification alone cannot be considered to create shareholder value. It also flagged as problematic the structure under which Daou Technology, constrained by the Newspaper Act’s 50% cap on conglomerates’ ownership of newspaper companies, would have to bear additional funding burdens while sharing management control with CJ. It noted that if the goal is to secure group-level control, the interests of controlling shareholders—including Dow Data and former Daou Kiwoom Group Chairman Kim Ik-rae’s family—could conflict with those of ordinary shareholders.
AVI expects the transaction to further complicate Daou Technology’s governance and widen the stock’s discount. By AVI’s estimate, Daou Technology’s share price was trading at a roughly 62% discount to its net asset value (NAV) as of the 30th of last month. AVI analyzed that the discount stems not from the quality of the company’s assets but from investor concerns over capital allocation and the complex intermediate holding company structure. It forecast that the discount rate will widen further when the burden of jointly managing a loss-making newspaper with uncertain future funding needs is added.
As an alternative, AVI proposed share buybacks and cancellation. It calculated that buying and canceling shares at the current discount level would retire about 2,630 won (approximately $2) worth of estimated NAV per 1,000 won (approximately $0.75) spent on purchases. The 190 billion won amounts to about 14% of Daou Technology’s market capitalization. AVI recalled that management said in September it would consider share buybacks after the data center begins operations, and stressed that “if the funds cannot be used for buybacks at this point, they should not be used to invest in a newspaper company in workout either.”
The public letter follows the failure of earlier private communications. AVI sent a private letter to Daou Technology’s board on the 21st of last month and received a reply on the 30th, but judged that the response did not address its core concerns. Daou Technology reportedly replied at the time that the board was deliberating the transaction after external valuation and legal advice.
The credit rating industry views the financial burden itself as manageable. Korea Ratings estimated that if Daou Technology raises the entire 250 billion won (approximately $187.4 million) acquisition price through borrowing, its standalone net debt would rise from 100.7 billion won (approximately $75.5 million) at the end of June to 350.7 billion won (approximately $262.8 million), but that this would be manageable given the company’s cash generation capacity. However, as AVI points out, if increased borrowing burdens overlap with the incorporation of a loss-making business, tension with shareholders over capital allocation priorities is expected to continue for the time being.
AVI argued that the special committee should review all major decisions remaining until the closing of the transaction and report its results and recommendations to the board. It also called for clear disclosure of three procedures: valuation and financial/legal review, and independent directors’ review and assessment. What stance Daou Technology takes by the 30th of this month is emerging as a variable that will determine whether the transaction is completed and how the share price moves.
Source: finance.biggo.com



