This story was partially inspired by an article in The Washington Post entitled “Mercedes cannot put market forces in reverse”. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/11/16/german-mercedes-workers-risk-plant-closures-by-refusing-work-40-hours/
My Dad was in the auto business in my youth in the sixties and I have a lifelong interest in the auto industry and have been an auto enthusiast all my life. I grieved as I watched the auto enthusiasts and engineers who managed the industry in the fifties and sixties replaced by MBAs and bean counters who believed that the customers would not care if they cut costs and quality. The quality of Detroit iron was the world standard in the fifties for reliability, and the first true 100,000 mile engines came out of Detroit in the fifties.
Detroit starting in the seventies failed to adopt modern manufacturing methods, thinking that what they had was the best in the world. They also were wedded to big auto platforms with big heavy push rod cast iron V-8s that they loaded with options that raised costs. This created an opening for the Japanese and Germans to enter our market with cheap automobiles with high gas mileageand surprisingly enough after a few false starts, amazing reliability. The Germans brought better handling and performance with reasonable fuel economy. They also brought a more modern styling esthetic with superior use of interior space.
As a result of mismanagement, Detroit began to lose market share and this culminated with the gradual loss of roughly half of U.S. market share to foreign manufacturers. In the luxury market German vehicles began to take over as Detroit under the influence of the bean counters failed to meet the quality and technology of foreign luxury vehicles. Nor did Detroit have any real competition for the VW Bug that sold by the 100,000.
In recent years Detroit has fought back producing vehicles that are more reliable than German vehicles and approach the reliability of Japanese vehicles in some cases. American firms began to adopt more streamlined manufacturing techniques and integrated manufacturing throughout North America with plants in Canada and Mexico. These were specialty plants with each plant building portions of the assembly. Specialized plant also assembled the entire vehicle. Ultimately the output of these plants equalled the best of American manufacturing. The cost savings were huge and began to make American cars cost and quality competitive with the best from Germany and Japan.
Trump has basically junked the North American Free Trade Agreements in favor of his tariffs which have raised the price of critical materials like aluminum and manufactured parts from Canada and Mexico. The portions of the manufacturing process for vehicles made in Canada and Mexico cannot be transferred back to the U.S. without the expenditure of billions. So currently the U.S. trucks and autos prices have increased tremendously due to the Trump tariffs and the reciprocal tariffs of other countries. The U.S. auto industry was a world integrated industry with parts for U.S. vehicles made all over the world. Parts were supplied from Brazil, Poland, Ukraine (They make our electrical harnesses!) and almost every manufacturing country in the world. The tariffs have made the U.S. world integrated auto manufacturing unprofitable long term. Likewise the integration of the auto industry that Trump has destroyed has also impacted the entire European auto industry destroying their profitability.
Europe and Japan have huge stakes in the American market and the tariffs have resulted in loss of market share. At the same time, China has very cleverly allowed American, German and Japanese makers to manufacture vehicles in China provided that Chinese firms were the controlling owners to a large degree. To the largest extent over the last ten years, we have trained the Chinese and they have transferred advanced auto technology and developed their own, such that they have world dominating vehicles at lower prices than any other place in the world. Their plants are heavily automated, and they are distributing autos at below cost and undermining sales of other nations’ cars everywhere.
Chinese cars aren’t coming to the U.S due to a 100% tariff, which was even supported by Democrats as these are government subsidized vehicles sold at less than cost. But due to the Trump tariffs and the disruption of auto manufacturing in Canada and Mexico, both nations are making deals with China to manufacture and distribute Chinese vehicles in their nations. Already, Chinese vehicles are about half of the new cars sold in Mexico. By the time Trump leaves office I expect that China will dominate the market in Canada as well. This is all due to Trump’s stupidity.
So how does this impact the U.S.? Well under Trump’s rule, the U.S. would have to spend billions to re integrate all aspects of manufacturing in the U.S. Also as many metals plants in the U.S. have closed due to the failure to modernize and also due to anti-union bias, we would still have to buy materials overseas that are now subject to high tariffs thanks to Trump. The only way that the U.S. auto industry survives is as a tariff protected enclave with higher costs and more expensive cars. The only foreign manufacturers allowed will have their plants in the U.S. The problem with current U.S. manufacturing of foreign vehicles is that the drive trains in almost every case are made in their native countries. If Trump starts taxing those drive trains, then foreign manufacture would probably cease. The U.S. does not any longer have the manufacturing base, the skilled labor or the materials to produce the engines and transmissions that Europe, Japan, China and Korea produce in quantity. China now dominates the manufacturing of electric vehicles worldwide as well as the components to manufacture those vehicles.
Thanks to Trump, the U.S. is writing off billions expended in the design and manufacturing of EV’s while the rest of the world is expanding their capacity. So the U.S. is headed for a time of obsolete vehicles and an economy dependent on carbon fuels. Our vehicles will be adequate, but not state of the art compared to the rest of the world. The profits of American makers will also be damaged because they are no longer competitive in the world market. GM’s profits in China have already fallen precipitously.
The North American Free Trade Agreements were specifically designed to meet the competition from China by in part utilizing the low wage workers in Mexico, the ores, metallurgy and manufacturing prowess of Canada integrated into a system that also sold those vehicles throughout North America and the world at competitive prices. In return for this development of an auto industry in their countries, they would continue to keep import barriers against China. That is all gone now and the blow to the U.S. auto industry has not been fully realized. The certainty is that we have lost Mexico and Canada as markets for automobiles, and lots of other U.S. goods. We will shortly have lost our limited market in China. So U.S. cars will only be sold in the U.S. and the only foreign cars will be made here. The overall impact will be more expensive and inferior cars in the U.S. The U.S. in order to keep Chinese cars out of the U.S. will be subject to retaliatory barriers from China. The U.S. is dependent upon China for so many things that the eventual trade war this will provoke could devastate the U.S. economy.
Should the U.S. further tariff imports from Japan, Korea and Europe, the effect will be devastating to their economies. Those countries will have no choice but to resort to China to make up for the loss of the U.S. market. To get access to the Chinese market for anything they will have to allow Chinese vehicles into their countries. The net effect will be the loss of at least half of their domestic market share to China. Like the U.S. there will be huge loss of jobs in Germany. Massive layoffs have already started at VW. So thanks to Trump we will soon be looking at an integrated world economy run by China, in which the U.S. has little part. The U.S. Dollar in this world will no longer be the world currency and the U.S. will find it much harder to print money to finance its debt through the sale of Treasury notes.
Oddly, the U.S. billionaires who financed MAGA don’t seem to realize that Trump has destroyed the world economy focused on the U.S. and the U.S. dollar. The auto industry that China is gaining ascendancy over is just one of the industries that will be lost. Gradually China will make it nearly impossible for significant manufacturing to occur outside of China. Teslas soon will only be sold in the U.S. as they have lost their edge to China in price, design, and advanced technology.
We put an idiot in charge of our country’s economy and as a result our country faces the prospect of being a distant second in almost everything. Our grandchildren are already suffering due to shrinking of job opportunities in the U.S. I contend that this is only going to get worse as the impacts of China’s dominance of the world economy causes even more contraction of our industry and economy. Ironically any skilled economist could have told a competent president and his advisors what the consequences of his economic strategy would be. It is just as disastrous as his war against Iran, only in this case it ends up as a war on the U.S and its citizens. And like the Iran war, we may well have already lost. The Biden initiatives in the areas of green economy, renewable energy, infrastructure expansion and electric transportaion, which have been discarded by Trump were our last best chance to meet the Chinese challenge. A sad and unnecessary result.
We’ll get straight to the point: The financial hardships that Daily Kos is facing this year are tough.
We continue to be paywall-free. We continue to be supported by our readers, not billionaires or corporations. But we need to bring in more revenue. We are leaning on our community more than ever to help make ends meet. Can you donate $5 or more to support Daily Kos and our continued work?
Source: www.dailykos.com



