• Home  
  • Legislators Have a Moral and Legal Responsibility to Fix Criminal Justice Measures
Legislators Have a Moral and Legal Responsibility to Fix Criminal Justice Measures
- Crime & Justice

Legislators Have a Moral and Legal Responsibility to Fix Criminal Justice Measures

Yes, voters approved ballot propositions 132, increasing fentanyl penalties, and 133, imposing life in prison for paid sex with a minor. Voters approved the second measure by nearly a two-to-one margin, 62% to 38%. Nevertheless, these measures are badly written, and in some cases they impose grotesquely unjust criminal sanctions that violate the U.S. and

Yes, voters approved ballot propositions 132, increasing fentanyl penalties, and 133, imposing life in prison for paid sex with a minor. Voters approved the second measure by nearly a two-to-one margin, 62% to 38%.

Nevertheless, these measures are badly written, and in some cases they impose grotesquely unjust criminal sanctions that violate the U.S. and Colorado constitutions. Therefore, legislators have a moral and legal responsibility to clean up the language of the measures. Colorado’s Democratic supermajority should, in these cases, do their jobs as elected representatives. Thankfully, they already appear likely to do so.

Generally, we should watch for two main types of problems regarding direct democratic action.

First, if voters fully know what they’re doing, but what they’re doing flagrantly violates people’s constitutional rights, say, by imposing censorship, banning abortion, or imprisoning people based on arbitrary characteristics, then legislators (and courts) are constitutionally bound to block or refine the democratic action.

Second, if voters do not fully know what they’re doing, say, because they are voting by mood affiliation or vibes, then we should not take a democratic result as fully representative of informed public opinion anyway. This year, with so many measures on the ballot, we should be particularly worried that voters did not always have time to fully research and understand the implications of every measure.

To help resolve such problems is a major reason we rely on representative governance, and again the legislature has a responsibility to take corrective action.

The Fentanyl Measure

Fields

Prop. 132 is the only measure associated with the conservative group Advance Colorado to pass. Michael Fields, president of the group, was the designated representative for a total of five ballot measures, with the name Advance Colorado attached to a sixth. Two other measures were represented by Suzanne Taheri of West Group, an Advance-aligned law firm. The fentanyl measure lists Fields with West Group, along with Taheri. (See Quentin Young’s discussion of Advance Colorado.)

Summary language from the Blue Book explains, “Proposition 132 makes possession of any amount of fentanyl a felony [and] requires a mandatory minimum 8-year prison sentence for any quantity of fentanyl distribution.” The actual statutory language is six pages of dense legalese which few voters read in detail.

There definitely is an argument for harshly punishing someone who knowingly or even recklessly sells extremely dangerous drugs that, due to their unmarked composition and potency, cause some users to overdose. Often, people who overdose on fentanyl did not even know the drugs they consumed contained it.

But Prop. 132 imposes wildly excessive penalties for possession (which I believe is not rights-violating and therefore should not be criminal) as well as for sharing a small quantity of drugs with friends, even if the person did not know fentanyl was present, only a minuscule amount of fentanyl was mixed in, no money was exchanged, and no health crisis was caused.

Thus, Prop. 132 straightforwardly violates the Eighth Amendment‘s provision against “cruel and unusual punishments.”

The measure, by empowering prosecutors to threaten defendants with absurdly long sentences if they don’t plea bargain to a lesser offense, also severely undercuts the Sixth Amendment’s guarantee to a jury trial.

Colorado’s Bill of Rights contains comparable language regarding punishments and jury trials. Legislators who take their oaths of office seriously, then, must reform the language in question.

Left unchanged, the language of Prop. 132 almost certainly also would kill people, likely hundreds per year, for reasons discussed by the Colorado Criminal Justice Reform Coalition. The mechanism for the increased harm is obvious: By threatening to impose severe criminal sanctions for the sharing of drugs, the legal language would make people less likely to help those suffering overdose seek prompt medical attention. This constitutes another very strong reason for legislators to intervene.

Overbroad Trafficking Language

Sexually assaulting a child is one of the worst crimes there is, properly punished severely. In approving Prop. 133, voters probably were responding to the horrific nature of sex crimes against minors. That does not change the fact that the measure is badly written and violates the same punishments and jury provisions of the federal and state constitutions.

Prop. 133 adds to the definition of “human trafficking of a minor for sexual servitude” cases where a person “knowingly trades anything of monetary value to buy or sell sexual activity with a minor,” on punishment of “life in prison without parole or release.”

In most contexts, buying sex with a minor indeed warrants a harsh criminal penalty. But we also have to look to the marginal cases. Here I’ll outline two hypotheticals where life in prison obviously constitutes absurdly unjust overpunishment.

  1. Colorado has so-called “Romeo and Juliet” laws that allow an adult to have sex with a minor, so long as the two are close in age. So an 18-year-old (an adult) having consensual sex with a 17-year-old (a minor) is not a crime. But if the 17-year-old says, “I’ll have sex with you if you give me the latest video game,” and the other person consents, or if the 18-year-old offers her 17-year-old boyfriend $20 to have sex, then the adult is subject to automatic life in prison under Prop. 133. Obviously that is a grotesquely unjust outcome, and legislators should not allow grotesque injustices.
  2. An 18-year-old paying a 17-year-old for sex, in the context of prostitution, is a serious crime normally deserving of substantial criminal penalties. Yet, again, life in prison constitutes extreme overpunishment.
    The language of Prop. 133 does not distinguish between violently raping a 7-year-old and paying for sex with a 17-year-old sex worker. That is hardly justice. The latter crime, while serious, does not merit a lifetime sentence. What the proper sentencing guidelines should be is a matter for legislators and criminal justice experts, but the mandatory minimum under Prop. 133 is wrong.

The language of Prop. 133 also threatens to target victims of exploitation in some cases. Onnastasia Cole of the Colorado Coalition Against Sexual Assault explained“Rather than stopping child sex trafficking, Proposition 133 would punish victims who were methodically targeted, groomed, and sexually exploited as harshly as their traffickers for crimes their traffickers forced or coerced them to commit. This would make it even more difficult for victims to seek help.”

Again, for legislators to take seriously their oaths of office, they must reform this language.

The legal argument for reform is a slam-dunk. The laws should be carefully written to achieve justice, not sloppily written to allow extreme injustices. Yet it is also worth briefly exploring how it came to be that such a poorly worded measure appeared on the ballot.

The designated representatives for Prop. 133 are Erin Lee of Protect Kids Colorado, which aims to promote alleged “biblical and biological truth,” and Michelle Austin of Protect our Children. Austin also heads a conservative consulting firm. Not coincidentally, these are the same designated representatives behind the two ballot measures restricting transgender participation in sports and transgender surgeries for minors. So I don’t think it’s too surprising that organizations caught up in a moral panic about transgender people also produced a badly worded measure about sex trafficking.

Regardless, the measure on trafficking should be evaluated on its own merits, apart from the personalities who promoted it. When evaluated objectively, the language demands legislative reform, again, if legislators intend to fulfill their oaths to uphold the federal and state constitutions.


Ways for People in Crisis To Get Help

Editor’s Note: This article includes references to sexual violence. We’ve included the resources below for people who want to seek help.

Colorado Human Trafficking Hotline – 24/7 confidential support, resource referrals, and a place to report tips about sex or labor trafficking in Colorado.

You Have The Right Colorado – Information to help survivors understand the rights and options available to them.

Wings – Supporting adult survivors of childhood sexual abuse in Colorado.

Safe Horizon – National victim service organization, with a hotline and other assistance.

Rape, Abuse, and Incest National Network (RAINN) — supports survivors, holds perpetrators accountable, and creates safer communities.

Darkness to Light — Empowers adults to prevent, recognize, and react responsibly to child sexual abuse through awareness, education, and stigma reduction.

Brave Movement – Survivors and allies joining together to push for change.

Source: coloradotimesrecorder.com

About Us

Toolq Media Is a Global News Platform Covering the Latest Developments and Breaking Stories from Around The World, Including World News, Business, Finance, Technology, Health, Politics, Science, Entertainment, Sports, and More.

Toolq

Toolq @2026. All Rights Reserved.